Historically, thermostatic mixing valves (TMVs) have played a vital role in protecting vulnerable users. However, recent scrutiny has cast doubt on their efficacy, prompting some facilities to explore alternative solutions, says Carole Armstrong, Senior Marketing manager at Delabie, who here asks whether thermostatic mixing valve technology still has a role to play in modern healthcare settings.
In healthcare environments, the balance between anti-scalding safety and the risk of Legionella infection is a perennial issue. Temperature control regimes have always been crucial for managing the risk of waterborne infection while mitigating the risk of scalding. Thermostatic mixing valves (that comply with NHS D08 performance specifications, i.e. are TMV3-approved) have typically played a significant role in protecting vulnerable users, but in recent years their reputation has become somewhat tarnished. Alternative mechanical solutions have been implemented to address the concerns raised by estates teams. So, will the thermostatic mixing valve (TMV) be consigned to the great scrap metal recycling heap, or does it still have a role to play in today’s healthcare environments?
Legionella control regimes in healthcare domestic hot water distribution systems mean that hot water at 55 °C is circulated right up to the point of use to prevent bacterial proliferation. However, this elevates the risk of scalding at the point of use. The Health & Safety Executive's Technical Guidance for Legionnaire's disease (HSG274 Part 2)¹ states that TMVs should be used where there is a high scalding risk, such as where there is full body immersion for baths and showers, and for hand washbasins and sinks where the risk is highest — i.e. for people who are infirm, elderly, very young, or significantly mentally or physically disabled, and also those with sensory loss.
TMVs provide optimal anti-scalding safety. A temperature-sensitive cell adjusts the incoming hot and cold water flow so that the mixed water output is controlled to a very high degree of sensitivity. Variations in the incoming water temperature and pressure are compensated for immediately, ensuring that the mixed water is delivered at a safe, constant temperature to the user. The thermostatic cell reacts instantly if there is a cold water supply failure, shutting off the hot water supply. Likewise, if the hot water supply fails, the cold supply shuts off too, meeting the TMV3 requirements for anti-scalding safety, i.e. failsafe. So, if user safety and comfort are preserved, and the risk of Legionella is mitigated, why have TMVs become technology non-grata?
Log in or register FREE to read the rest
This story is Premium Content and is only available to registered users. Please log in at the top of the page to view the full text.
If you don't already have an account, please register with us completely free of charge.
